124 405

Cited 0 times in

Quality Evaluation of Randomized Controlled Trials on Complementary and Alternative Medicine

Authors
Oh, KS; Kim, KS; Park, JW; Kang, JY
Citation
Asian nursing research, 1(3):153-164, 2007
Journal Title
Asian nursing research
ISSN
1976-13172093-7482
Abstract
Purpose: This study aims to describe the research characteristics and analyze the methodological quality of randomized clinical trials on complementary and alternative medicine (CAM).



Methods: A total of 76 studies using randomized controlled trials (RCTs) on CAM (16 by Koreans, 60 by internationals) published in the 6 years from 2000 to 2005 were reviewed systematically and analyzed with assessment criteria developed by the researchers on the basis of Jadad guidelines.



Results: Most of the studies were carried out in the area of medicine, nursing and CAM. More than 80% of the study subjects were patients. CAM modalities for independent variables were mainly on energy medicine, mind-body medicine and manipulative and body-based practices, while dependent variables were mostly physiological and psychological indexes. Most of the studies utilized randomization (93.4%) and identified the dropout rate (90.8%), whereas allocation concealment (49.3%) and double-blinding (18.9%) were specified in a small number of studies. The overall quality of RCTs based on the assessment criteria of this study was satisfactory. However, the quality score of the Korean studies (2.87) was lower than that of the international studies (3.37).



Conclusion: The methodological objectivity of CAM studies has been improving in spite of controversy over the scientific bases of CAM. More Korean studies with rigorous experimental design are needed to build up the evidence-based practice of CAM.
Keywords
complementary and alternative medicinerandomized controlled trialsresearch methodologyquality
Appears in Collections:
Journal Papers > College of Nursing Science > Nursing Science
AJOU Authors
박, 지원
Full Text Link
Files in This Item:
Asian nursing research_1(3)_153-164.pdfDownload
Export
RIS (EndNote)
XLS (Excel)
XML

qrcode

해당 아이템을 이메일로 공유하기 원하시면 인증을 거치시기 바랍니다.

Items in DSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.

Browse